Skip to main content

The Con in Consumer

The luxury of browsing items for purchase from the comfort of a bed in a questionable state of undress (seng'enge ni ng'ombe haute couture) has been available to us for quite a while now. Call me old fashioned but it does not compare to the peculiar satisfaction of sauntering down well-stocked aisles adorned in endless rows of colourful brands. Don't act shocked. Surely you are familiar with aisle 2? That paradise comprised of mesmerising motifs of coffees, cocoas and teas in small, medium and large from a variety of manufacturers. A dazzling display of order that is mythical in most of our homesteads.

Photo by Charles Gao on Unsplash

Either way, replacing online shopping with a proper trip to wherever your current Nakumatt equivalent is, requires a household audit to keep the panic of forgetting the toilet cleaner for the fourth time at bay. Balancing out the excitement is a seriousness driven by my buying power in a fickle economy.

Enter the Dragon

I am on location at the new sokomart and have trouble finding the entrance although the luggage drop point hinted at what would be the entry. There, a hefty, towering Simba Mbili guard halts my progress with the security wand to my torso and bellows, hatuuingilii hapa (This is not the entrance). If I could, I'd turn redder than my mama mboga’s in-season tomatoes. Walking back, head hung low and hands baptised in sanitiser, the embarrassment is near-fatal but I'll purchase glucose that will possibly reboot my spirit. Mortified, I complied with her directive.

Shop

Level 2 of market mania is unlocked. Locating a trolly in decent working order was almost as likely as finding an honest politician. Most had squeaky wheels. Those in working order often had a single rebellious one constantly threatening to bring the entire shopping operation to a halt. Passing the wheel test, they would be sticky with what I could only guess is fruit juice 😳 The struggle to find a clean handbasket - because the carts were far too massive for my humble shopping list- was just as tortuous. When I finally decided to go for the cart, the aforementioned rebel wheel actively resisted my advancement.

Level 3: Get in, do what you need to do and get out. The cheat sheet for this level is a grocery list. I require the manoeuvring skill of a cartographer and a navy SEAL to acquire everything listed from detergent to soy sauce in record time. It's a game I play to see how easy it is to navigate through aisles. A labyrinth of shoppers' neglected trollies, playful toddlers and boulders of supermarket attendants restocking the shelves. Lord knows few of us would meet Him should a fire drill be conducted. The dulcet DJ Adrian mix attempted to recalibrate my dampened mood. Although I enjoyed being in massive stores when I was younger, now my priorities have shifted to efficiency as opposed to wonder. The frustration of having tare spices and cereals three aisles apart from the pre-packed counterparts was giving anything but. I understand wanting people to spend more time in the store to increase their chances of impulse buying in this economy_but is this the best way to do it?

Boss Level

With the help of mandatory signage and a few kind staff, I managed to get to checkout. It's no Sunday evening yet the lines were formidable. Alfred Hitchcock movie anyone? Although the queues were fairly straight, the dolly zoom was in effect to see where the cashier sat. Terribly unfortunate for the Gen Z clutching a coke zero and gum to be caught in the same line as me seeing as the less than 5 items counter was overridden by massive shoppers. Oh well, si ni life 🤷🏽‍♀️


Design Opportunities

Wayfinding: The entrance and exit. For first-time shoppers of a new branch, this creates the initial impression of the store more so for first-timers of the brand. Solution: Have a single entryway making the luggage centre central to manage the flow of customers. Understandably, security is the deciding factor - how likely is shoplifting- for the store's porosity. Balancing a show of power, through virtual and in-person surveillance, and extending trust to the public i.e. I believe you are a good person and I trust you to pay for anything you walk out of the store with. This will need to operate on an assumption that people are intrinsically good and want to live up to the value of honesty, an invisible design outcome. see halo effect

Findability: positioning the fresh fruit and bakery as the anchor products is a strategy that currently works to promote the capitalistic dream that makes the world go round. In the same vein, organising products in a complimentary fashion would ease a grocery run for the consumer. It's word associations for commodities. Additionally, on the subcategories of products, having a visual matrix of type vs brand helps with choice-making.

Think 1. types of milk i.e. whole milk, skimmed, lactose-free milk, plant-based milk 2. quantity of milk - 200ml, 500ml, 1 ltr, 3ltr -plus everything in between- and 3. brand (free sponsorship? I think not). Honouring brand agreements, how can the store cater to the time-constrained customer instead of making it a non-consensual treasure hunt?


Climate friendliness: begins in the parking lot, for those who want to cycle to the store are there bike racks. Especially for the midweek light shopping that doesn't require the SUV to struggle to find parking. The tare system introduced in the majority of the stores can offer reduced pricing for those who bring their own containers as well as reduce operational costs for the supermarket.

Social contracts: We can employ some degree of social intelligence by respecting tills designated for less than 5 items. We have at one point in our lives experienced unmanned booths or teller boxes what is one more? However, during rush hours these tills can serve customers outside of this bracket but anyone that meets the criteria should be served next. Say what you mean, mean what you say because with great power comes great responsibility. Changes in shopping behaviour can be affected by stores which can play into efforts to use consumerism in the increasing sustainability in the Anthropocene. That said, happy shopping :)

Comments

  1. It’s always that one wheel on the cart that will embarrass the hell out of you 🤦🏾‍♀️😂

    Beautiful piece

    ReplyDelete
  2. You're preaching to the choir!
    Thank you 😊

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great read indeed in the pursuit of cudt

    ReplyDelete
  4. Note to self, buy glucose whenever I use the wrong entrance 😎. Great article.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Helps to have a patco or two in the pocket in anticipation.

      Delete
  5. Boniface Munyao6 August 2023 at 16:44

    A wonderful piece, demarcation of entries and exits clearly causes less frustration and eases your experience. Positioning things that go together closer helps in recalling items you may have forgotten or spark an instinctive urge to get some before the other is depleted. To close I’d like to say I’m fairly certain that squeaky wheel was caused by a child trying to drift that cart like a fast and the furious car! (I was that kid ps: the wheels on the cart photo captures the real thing 💯 🤣) Looking forward to the next piece!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The circle of life ey? If it wasn't for your drifting skills practice, this article may have never existed 😎

      Delete
  6. You just reminded me shopping in a supermarket increases my chases of adding new items in my next shopping list, the audacity tu na hii economy tu🤦‍♀️

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There probably should be a support group for impulse buyers. Wakupate nyuma ya tent gani?

      Delete
  7. Carts🤣, you decide to pick the smaller one since you just picking few items, una end up kuniama _bedding_the whole time, and your just their thinking should you return it ama just continue disrespecting your posture

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 😅 it's what keeps chiropractors in business Tweety

      Delete
  8. Nice read, I believe some of the 'disorganisation' is by design to increase the time used at the supermarket which in turn will have you buy more than what you needed,

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point. Do you actually buy more or try to get to the exit ASAP to escape the frustration?

      Delete
  9. Oh my days, this was me at a certain sokomart, literally finished shopping and actually had to ask where the tills are, how bizarre, especially since I had the squeaky wheel and the luggage section was more than 100m from the entrance. Design's purpose to make life easier is commonly ignored - let me know even go that climate friendliness bit. In this capitalist society with great greed, how do we incentivise such goodwill - cause for sure a good talking to won't cut it.

    Also thinking about some kind of rating based on what consumers need for supermarkets navigation.

    As always, thank you for rearranging our frustrations into a well written piece.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aaaah, the universality of the human experience. This, "Design's purpose to make life easier is commonly ignored'' is a powerful summation of the article.

      Delete
  10. Oh my I loved reading this piece so much Doll, it's like you took my shopping frustrations and put them in words
    Another design flaw is ventilation, I've had to get out of several places lest I fainted in there. Most marts are not designed for a certain number of people but do they care, hell nooooo,sigh capitalism
    And network, daaaamm, there's this day I was shopping for pads and I wanted to get the right ones for my sister I send her photos via WhatsApp but the messages could not be delivered because no network safe to say I picked the wrong ones🤣
    These places need to make sure express counters are available and being used for what they were invented for

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We really are living one life 😂. With internet being a peer to basic needs, how apt that both connectivity and breathing were less than a priority for the sokomart to provide. Perhaps if they could charge for it...

      Delete
  11. Let me tell you Maina!!! I had such an experience or did we visit the same place?? The entrance was in the not obvious place and to add to that the 1st things I met felt misplaced. Steaks at the entrance !!!! for heavens sake. Well I designed for them in my head maybe I should share with them what I felt....
    Now don't even remind me of the day I picked a cart that was over squeaky and on top of that pushing it needed me to be one of those muscled weight lifters. then the damn thing doesn't take direction well kept going where it wants not where i want. Needless to say it was abandoned like the ones you encountered lol

    ReplyDelete
  12. I couldn't relate more with a well written piece as I did with this. First, the struggle of getting a cart that is in a peacful relationship with all its wheels then actually getting my shopping done without having to scan all aisles looking for items I couldn't find or were in a specific spot before and have now been moved to another section without notice. Wueh! I have actually struggled with some of these places while shopping.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great read. Not too trusting of people on the social contract bit though. I'm tagging the social & behavioral engineers on that one. Everyone gets a piece of the pie😅

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hello,
    Oh my goodness.
    What a piece well written.
    I can totally relate to that.
    online shopping has really come through for me a lot.
    seems like most supermarkets have almost the same frustrations.
    I strongly agree that some supermarkets are designed in a way that we should spend more time there…because the number of times you can go in circles just to find one thing…🤦🏾‍♀️mostly for first time clients, the rest is history.

    I love it!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Awesome read. Love how you integrate the photos. I mean if Capitalism is the problem (or the solution🤷‍♂️) one might argue that a better experience may lead to more visits...and more opportunities for impulse buys y'know probability and that. Besides...the less time i spend looking for whatever....the more time i can spend getting that $$$. Plus...why does the meat section have to smell so...well...dead?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Poetic and analytic piece, at the same time. The supermarket is a paradox of order, wear and tear...and is also a magnet designed to generate a struggle between what you want and what you need. The experience with the "bouncer " is part of the story. Very compelling writing ✍

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dark Path

P ristine tree-lined walkways offer a glorious mix of visual and thermal pleasures along Dennis Pritt in the heat of a low hanging equatorial sun. Similarly, warm hues of street lighting must evoke romance in a sweltering Njaanuary evening, one would think. Even though I have traversed this road countless times on my way to work, the evening walk is hellish. That's harsh, the devil probably has tiki torches and fire cauldrons illuminating his real estate. I stumble along at an eighth of my normal speed, careful not to step in dog doo. How I wish I was bat-girl, using sonar, I could find my way home much quicker in this canine-doodie embellished infrastructural maze. Courtesy: Pixabay on Pexels Psychologically I am in a state. A state of short-lived scares dancing in harmonious disquiet. Please note, I'm a small-framed female invisibly (due to the blinding darkness) lacking the art of Krav Maga.   Deduction : poorly lit areas do not inspire the feeling of safety. Perhaps t...

Location Unknown

Photo by Mario Ayala via dribble It might be safe to assume you do not have a personal chauffeur if you aren’t in the 1%. Save for the occasional COVID Uber where you ride back left with a little less than the stipulated social distance between you and the driver in the jam-weaving Suzuki Alto 400. However, using taxi-hailing applications on the regular wouldn't amount to a financially sustainable practice - unless you are Bezos, at which point you might as well own the franchise and its competitors. So, reliable public transport is the way to ride. However, the term reliable has lost its lustre to a point we do not consider all it encompasses: proper pricing, predictable routes, effective communication and calculable timing. No one, forgive the generalisation, living in the outskirts of Nairobi can say, "I paid normal fare rates despite it raining cats and dogs", not with their chest! Meaning people have had to stow their pride and make the tuma kitu call that they had ...